Speak To An Attorney Today 323-524-8994

Blog

Evidence Preservation in a Truck Accident Case - Guide

Posted by Alan Fassonaki | Apr 28, 2023

In Los Angeles truck accident litigation, the most important point to remember is that a truck accident claim should not be treated like a typical car accident case. In actuality, these types of personal injury cases are vastly distinct, necessitating a distinct approach from the outset. Failure to recognize the particulars of a truck accident lawsuit might have disastrous effects. In conclusion, the primary distinctions that must be considered in a truck accident case stem from two particular facts:

The transportation logistics sector is subject to numerous complex federal laws and regulations. Insurance coverage is typically extensive, but understanding the potential layers of coverage necessitates a certain amount of experience.

The Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Regulations (FMSVR) will almost undoubtedly affect every aspect of a truck accident lawsuit. These rules will affect everything from establishing negligence and liability to preserving trial evidence. Remember that these regulations require all trucking companies to maintain substantial insurance policy limits, but your truck accident attorney must know where to search for maximum effectiveness.

Disclaimer: This image is a stock photo obtained from Envato Elements and does not depict the actual scene, individuals, or events described.

Preserving Evidence After a Truck Accident

The strength of your truck accident case will depend on your capacity to prove that the truck driver's carelessness was what led to your injuries. A typical trucking accident case will show significantly more evidence than a normal vehicle accident claim due to variables specific to the trucking business, federal rules, and technological improvements. To establish liability, identify additional defendants and insurance coverage, and refute allegations of comparative or contributory carelessness, this information may be essential. Despite the fact that practically all truck accident cases have this evidence, a capable lawyer is aware that it must first be maintained. The approach to the case should be based on this right away.

Your personal injury attorney's first order of business will be to ensure the preservation of all vehicle accident-related evidence. The sooner you consult with a truck accident attorney, the quicker they will be able to initiate this arduous process. After accepting a truck accident case, a competent truck accident attorney should always perform the following:

  • Send a preservation letter. Your truck accident attorney should send this promptly to all potential defendants who may possess crucial evidence for your case.  The 49 C.F.R. section 395.8 mandates that transportation companies keep certain evidence for six months. However, these regulations may not protect everything, and transportation companies can use them to justify the destruction of evidence after this period without a preservation letter. An experienced truck accident attorney is aware that this letter must inform the recipient of their duty to preserve evidence and specify what evidence is being sought. Ambiguity in this letter will only serve to complicate the evidence-gathering process and provide cover for the transportation company. If a transportation company destroys evidence after receiving this letter, you should discuss your right to file a spoliation claim with your truck accident attorney.  
  • Locate and secure any involved trucks. Due to the severity of the majority of truck accidents, insurance companies typically inspect the site of the accident. They will use the opportunity to inspect and secure the involved semi-truck. Regardless of how fast you contact a truck accident attorney, you are already at a disadvantage in this regard. However, a competent truck accident attorney is aware that there are means to equalize the playing field. Your truck accident attorney should promptly take steps to locate and secure the truck, taking precautions to ensure that it is not manipulated or tampered with. Remember that a technological device known as a "black box" may be essential to your claim, but only if it is properly preserved and protected. 
  • Find and secure the vehicle of the plaintiff. The vehicle you were operating contains a vast quantity of crucial information. Whether it be the markings on the car's body or the tire tread wear, in the hands of a skilled accident reconstruction expert, preserving the vehicle you were driving can be the key to winning a truck accident case.
Disclaimer: This image is a stock photo obtained from Envato Elements and does not depict the actual scene, individuals, or events described.

Frequently Asked Questions About Preserving Evidence After a Truck Accident

Why is preserving evidence important after a truck accident?
Preserving evidence can help establish how the collision occurred, who may be responsible, and whether violations of applicable safety regulations contributed to the accident. Trucking-related evidence may also help identify additional potentially liable parties and available insurance coverage.

What evidence should be preserved after a commercial truck accident?
Depending on the circumstances, important evidence may include the truck's electronic data, driver logs, inspection and maintenance records, dispatch information, employment and training records, photographs and videos, witness information, accident reports, and the vehicles involved in the collision.

What is a preservation letter in a truck accident case?
A preservation letter, sometimes called a spoliation letter, puts relevant parties on notice that certain evidence relating to the accident should be preserved. The letter can identify specific records, vehicles, electronic information, and other materials that may become important in a personal injury claim or lawsuit.

What happens if a trucking company destroys important evidence?
If relevant evidence is destroyed after a party had a legal obligation to preserve it, the issue may constitute spoliation of evidence. The available remedies depend on the circumstances and applicable law. A truck accident attorney can evaluate whether evidence was improperly destroyed and what legal remedies may be available.

What is a truck's “black box,” and why is it important?
Commercial trucks may contain electronic systems that record information related to the truck's operation. Depending on the vehicle and its equipment, electronic data may provide information about factors such as speed, braking, engine activity, and other events surrounding a collision. Preserving this data promptly can be important because some electronic information may eventually be overwritten or become unavailable.

Should my damaged vehicle be preserved after a truck accident?
Potentially, yes. The condition of your vehicle may provide useful evidence regarding the mechanics and severity of the collision. Damage patterns, physical markings, tire condition, and other features may be examined by qualified experts when reconstructing an accident. Speak with an attorney before authorizing repairs, disposal, or destruction of a vehicle that may contain important evidence.

How soon should I contact a truck accident attorney?
It is generally beneficial to speak with an attorney as soon as reasonably possible after a serious truck accident. Early involvement gives an attorney an opportunity to identify potentially relevant evidence, determine who may possess it, and take appropriate steps to request its preservation.

Who may be liable for a truck accident in Los Angeles?
Liability depends on the facts of the collision. Potentially responsible parties may include the truck driver, trucking or motor carrier company, vehicle owner, maintenance provider, cargo-loading company, manufacturer, or another party whose negligence contributed to the crash.

Are truck accident claims different from ordinary car accident claims?
They can be. Commercial trucking cases may involve federal and state regulations, multiple potentially responsible parties, substantial insurance coverage, specialized electronic evidence, and extensive company records. These factors can make investigating a truck accident claim more complex than investigating many passenger-vehicle collisions.

How can a Los Angeles truck accident attorney help preserve evidence?
An attorney can identify potentially relevant evidence, send preservation demands to appropriate parties, investigate the vehicles and accident scene, obtain available records and electronic data, interview witnesses, and work with qualified experts when necessary. Taking these steps early can help build a more complete picture of how the accident occurred.

Speak With a Los Angeles Truck Accident Attorney

Evidence can play a critical role in determining liability and the value of a truck accident claim. However, trucking companies and their insurers may possess important records, electronic data, inspection information, and other evidence that may not be preserved indefinitely. Acting promptly can help protect evidence before it is lost, overwritten, altered, or destroyed.
If you or a loved one has been injured in a commercial truck accident in Los Angeles, Fassonaki Law Firm, P.C. can evaluate the circumstances of the crash, identify potentially responsible parties, and take appropriate steps to preserve evidence relevant to your claim.
Contact Fassonaki Law Firm, P.C. today to schedule a free consultation with a Los Angeles truck accident attorney and learn about your legal options.

About the Author

Alan Fassonaki

What inspired me to practice personal injury law? I was 9 and imagining the win. My mother was driving me to my basketball game. My older sister came along to support me. While on the road, I thought about practice and replayed our team's game-plan in my mind. Suddenly, I hea...

Contact Us Today

Fassonaki Law Firm, P.C. is committed to answering your questions about Personal Injury law issues in Los Angeles, Calabasas, Agoura Hills, Thousand Oaks, Simi Valley, Woodland Hills, West Hills, and the San Fernando Valley.

We'll gladly discuss your case with you at your convenience. Contact Us today to schedule an appointment.

Menu